What should a baseline recovery card for a comparative claim make inspectable?
Imagine a review calling a paper sorter much faster without naming what it replaced. A baseline card protects that relative judgment from becoming an absolute speed promise. It checks the prior arrangement and task before an editor invents duration, comparison products or measured superiority absent from the available source account and its surrounding context.
Output columns: comparative_phrase; task; stated_baseline; baseline_source; outcome_meaning; precision_limit; safe_wording.
Decision check: If baseline remains unknown, use narrow attribution or remove the claim from a direct table. Do not infer the sorter is slow or ineffective.Identify the concrete review task
Copy the phrase and identify the task. Faster may concern finding papers, putting them away or assembly. Keep these distinct rather than assuming a typical office baseline or selecting the outcome that best supports the draft's preferred recommendation about general workflow improvement for every reader.
Inspect admissible supporting material
Include explicit descriptions of the prior arrangement. Exclude stereotypes and reconstructed workflows. Montage original references may clarify context, but a later summary naming a baseline needs traceable support before its phrase can be treated as part of the original writer's stated experience rather than a new analyst inference.
Assemble the decision artifact
Record outcome and precision. Subjective faster is not elapsed time. Preserve uncertainty and conditions instead of converting adjectives into minutes saved, inferring an unstated maximum or averaging unlike comparisons into a numerical performance result that nobody in the inspected material actually measured or reported with the necessary units.
Check the inference and action boundary
If baseline remains unknown, use narrow attribution or remove the claim from a direct table. Do not infer the sorter is slow or ineffective. The unresolved comparison limits wording, not every possible benefit under other circumstances, and automated agreement about a likely baseline cannot replace the missing original description.
Deliver the bounded review state
Deliver baseline state, outcome and safe text. Hold numerical claims lacking appropriate evidence. Precise layout and repeated paraphrases cannot expand the report into independent proof of superiority for all users, configurations or tasks, nor do they establish that every other product in the comparison was tested under matching conditions.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- Precise layout and repeated paraphrases cannot expand the report into independent proof of superiority for all users, configurations or tasks, nor do they establish that every other product in the comparison was tested under matching conditions.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.