What should a claim dependency card make inspectable?
For a considered example, a bicycle-bag comparison recommends a removable liner because it supposedly keeps other contents dry. The editor needs to know which premises must hold before that recommendation can stand. A dependency card exposes unsupported links without turning a plausible explanation into a demonstrated product outcome.
Worksheet columns: recommendation; necessary_premise; premise_source; evidence_basis; dependency_type; hold_reason; supported_alternative.
Decision check: Test the recommendation with the closure premise unresolved. If the advice no longer follows, mark that dependency as a hold.Define the decision unit
Write the final recommendation separately from premises about closure, liner construction and exposure conditions. Draw only necessary dependencies. Do not add impressive but irrelevant specifications that make the card appear rigorous without affecting whether the recommendation follows.
Choose admissible evidence
Admit sources describing the relevant liner and closure together. Exclude other bags sharing a brand but using another design. Read Montage coverage and preserve unavailable originals as unresolved supply rather than assuming they contain favorable or unfavorable evidence.
Build the working record
Attach a passage to each premise and label its basis: stated specification, reported experience or observed scene. Arrows organize reasoning; they are not additional evidence. A repeated summary cannot independently confirm the public account from which it derives.
Test the claim boundary
Test the recommendation with the closure premise unresolved. If the advice no longer follows, mark that dependency as a hold. Consider whether a narrower recommendation about separating contents survives without implying waterproofing or making an unsupported durability claim.
Deliver the review artifact
Hand over the card with its weakest necessary premise visible and a supported alternative sentence. Name the owner of the remaining evidence check. The decision to publish or buy remains separate from the logical relationship documented in this artifact.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The decision to publish or buy remains separate from the logical relationship documented in this artifact.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.