What should a hard-constraint evidence matrix contain?
For a considered example, a buying-guide brief requires a desk organizer that fits a stated shelf opening and needs no wall attachment. A compliance matrix treats both as hard conditions. Favorable public comments cannot compensate for a failed requirement, and an attractive unknown candidate cannot be labeled compliant merely because it seems likely to fit.
Editorial worksheet: candidate; hard_condition; stated_unit; evidence_passage; compliance_state; exclusion_reason; unresolved_check; owner_question.
Decision check: Remove candidates failing any hard condition from the compliant set. Label unknowns as unresolved rather than near matches.Establish the review object
Copy each condition exactly, keeping dimensions and attachment independent. Preserve stated units and any orientation requirement. Do not translate must fit into a subjective compactness label or reinterpret no wall attachment as minimal attachment without the owner's explicit change to the brief.
Inspect the relevant support
Include explicit dimensions or a demonstrated fit under matching conditions. Exclude visual estimates without reliable scale. Inspect Montage originals and retain absent measurements as unknown; a typical size inferred from the category cannot establish that a specific candidate satisfies the shelf opening.
Record the decision logic
Mark each candidate met, not met or unverified for every condition, attaching the relevant passage. Separate unknown from failed. A source naming dimensions may support fit arithmetic, but an unrelated report of easy setup does not establish the absence of wall attachment.
Apply the bounded disposition
Remove candidates failing any hard condition from the compliant set. Label unknowns as unresolved rather than near matches. Do not average criteria into a score that lets strong appearance or popularity cancel an incompatible dimension, mounting requirement or other explicit constraint.
Hand over the evidence state
Deliver the matrix with no silent relaxation. If nothing satisfies all conditions, state that result and present an owner question about next steps. The evidence artifact should expose the empty compliant set honestly rather than manufacturing a recommendation from insufficient or incompatible supply.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The evidence artifact should expose the empty compliant set honestly rather than manufacturing a recommendation from insufficient or incompatible supply.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.