What should a contested-correction evidence note explain?
Imagine a source author disputing a desk-tray guide's interpretation while the original words still permit several readings. A contested-correction note preserves passage, objection and clarification together. It avoids deciding by status or prior approval and separates the research assessment from the publisher's authorized decision about revised wording or a public correction.
Output columns: published_interpretation; objection; original_passage; clarification; assessment; editorial_options; unresolved_point.
Decision check: Offer narrower attribution, a hold or correction according to inspected evidence. Preserve genuine ambiguity rather than forcing a binary winner.Identify the concrete review task
Place published interpretation beside objection and original passage. Identify whether the dispute concerns quotation accuracy, content or emphasis. Do not rewrite the issue so either side appears to answer a proposition it never addressed in the available exchange or assume every objection constitutes a full retraction.
Inspect admissible supporting material
Include inspectable public clarification. Exclude unauthorized private statements and speculative motives. Use Montage original references where available; inaccessible language remains a gap rather than being replaced with a confident paraphrase presented as if it resolved the exact terms the source author says the article misunderstood.
Assemble the decision artifact
Assess whether clarification resolves, narrows or leaves the point contested. Explain consequential language without trust scores. Author status does not automatically validate every replacement, while prior editorial approval does not independently defeat new relevant context challenging the old interpretation or establish what the writer privately intended outside the published passage.
Check the inference and action boundary
Offer narrower attribution, a hold or correction according to inspected evidence. Preserve genuine ambiguity rather than forcing a binary winner. Several automated interpretations remain readings of the same language, not independent observations of the underlying experience or proof of the speaker's intended meaning in circumstances the source never explains.
Deliver the bounded review state
Deliver disputed point, assessment and options with unresolved states intact. Leave publication authority separate. The note supports fair review without alleging dishonesty, inferring private intent or claiming that documenting a disagreement establishes which product account is ultimately true beyond what can be read and attributed in the inspected public material.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The note supports fair review without alleging dishonesty, inferring private intent or claiming that documenting a disagreement establishes which product account is ultimately true beyond what can be read and attributed in the inspected public material.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.