What should a disagreement dossier by proposition preserve?
In a hypothetical editorial case, two reviewers oppose each other on portable whiteboards because one values carrying ease and the other needs a rigid writing surface. A proposition-based dossier makes the actual disagreement visible. It avoids collapsing different tasks into positive and negative sentiment or choosing a winner from the volume of public comments.
Worksheet columns: proposition; task_context; position_a; source_a; position_b; source_b; disagreement_kind; decision_dependency.
Decision check: Classify the disagreement as observation, interpretation or priority. Additional public evidence may clarify an observation, but a preference requires an owner choice.Define the decision unit
Write each disputed proposition separately, including portability and writing rigidity. Name the task behind each judgment. Keep value preferences distinct from observations so the dossier does not present one person's priority as factual disproof of another person's reported experience.
Choose admissible evidence
Include passages giving reasons and stated conditions; exclude bare approval reactions from the explanatory dossier. Inspect originals available through Montage results and preserve gaps. An unavailable passage cannot serve as an inferred vote for either position or establish the missing task context.
Build the working record
Place opposing accounts together only when conditions match sufficiently to address the same proposition. A desk easel and a floor stand may answer different questions. Record configuration mismatches rather than forcing a symmetrical debate between examples that are not directly comparable.
Test the claim boundary
Classify the disagreement as observation, interpretation or priority. Additional public evidence may clarify an observation, but a preference requires an owner choice. Do not average labels or use automated consensus to erase a substantive conflict that affects the recommendation.
Deliver the review artifact
Deliver shared observations, unresolved differences and conditional implications together. Link every position to its source and preserve minority reasoning. The dossier helps the owner choose for a stated task; it does not establish a universally best whiteboard or infer how all users would decide.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The dossier helps the owner choose for a stated task; it does not establish a universally best whiteboard or infer how all users would decide.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.