What should a fact-check handoff index establish?
In a hypothetical editorial case, a magazine editor receives a draft about home filing habits with dozens of links but no check order. A handoff index makes claims and unresolved passages independently reviewable. It gives the factual reviewer a usable route through the material without presenting organization as evidence that the assertions have already passed review.
Editorial worksheet: claim_number; draft_location; asserted_fact; source_passage; evidence_basis; limitation; check_order; reviewer_state.
Decision check: Order review by publication consequence, making headline-affecting gaps visible before minor wording questions. Explain the order in words rather than inventing a risk score.Establish the review object
Number factual claims in reading order, including captions and table notes. Distinguish statements about product behavior from attributed descriptions of a writer's experience. Opinion can remain labeled opinion, but factual premises inside that opinion still require an identifiable evidential basis.
Inspect the relevant support
Attach the exact relevant passage to each assertion. Exclude links with no stated role from the check queue, retaining them separately as discovery notes. Inspect Montage originals where available and label summary-only support instead of presenting it as direct source access.
Record the decision logic
Record evidence basis, configuration and known limitation for each row. A source describing one household's filing routine does not establish a general habit. Automated summaries can locate questions, but they do not provide additional independent confirmation of the same reported event.
Apply the bounded disposition
Order review by publication consequence, making headline-affecting gaps visible before minor wording questions. Explain the order in words rather than inventing a risk score. Keep hard factual requirements intact even if a lower-consequence item is easier to resolve quickly.
Hand over the evidence state
Deliver the index with reviewer status open and exact draft locations. Preserve unresolved claims rather than marking the folder complete because every row has a link. Acceptance of the handoff package remains distinct from factual approval and the authorized decision to publish.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- Acceptance of the handoff package remains distinct from factual approval and the authorized decision to publish.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.