What should a minimum-evidence shortfall notice explain?
Consider this hypothetical brief: a case-study editor requires three independent, inspectable examples before describing a storage habit as recurring. Only two eligible cases survive review. A shortfall notice preserves that local gate rather than redefining independence or counting summaries, while allowing the owner to consider a clearly labeled narrower illustration.
Editorial worksheet: local_gate; independence_rule; eligible_examples; rejected_candidates; unresolved_relationships; unmet_requirement; proposed_narrower_output.
Decision check: Recommend holding recurring-theme language or proposing a smaller case illustration. State what that change would and would not establish.Establish the review object
Record the local gate and define independence for this task. Explain that three is an editorial requirement, not a universal scientific threshold. Preserve the requested claim scope so a small illustrative case note cannot silently replace the requested recurring-theme finding and still be labeled complete.
Inspect the relevant support
Include separate documented experiences with inspectable support. Exclude syndicated versions, quotations and automated summaries as additional independent cases. Read Montage coverage and keep unavailable originals unresolved; their absence does not prove the theme is rare, but they cannot fill the inspectability requirement.
Record the decision logic
Show accepted and rejected candidates with reasons. Keep unknown relationships separate from known retellings. The point is to explain the shortfall fairly, not search for a permissive label that makes the third example count despite failing the same standard applied to the first two.
Apply the bounded disposition
Recommend holding recurring-theme language or proposing a smaller case illustration. State what that change would and would not establish. Obtain the owner's explicit scope decision rather than lowering the gate because a persuasive draft already exists or a deadline makes more review inconvenient.
Hand over the evidence state
Deliver the unmet count, surviving evidence and allowed narrower output. Preserve the original gate even after an authorized change. Passing format checks or producing detailed prose cannot satisfy a hard evidence requirement that remains short, and the notice must say so without euphemism.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- Passing format checks or producing detailed prose cannot satisfy a hard evidence requirement that remains short, and the notice must say so without euphemism.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.