What should a minority-rationale annex make inspectable?
For an illustrative research assignment, a team selects a portfolio case for a craft-tool guide, while one reviewer objects that it omits left-handed use. A minority annex keeps that material objection attached to the choice. It documents an unreviewed task without assuming either that the tool fails there or that the omission is harmless.
Worksheet columns: selected_case; minority_objection; evidence_basis; unreviewed_task; applicability_effect; owner_response; reuse_boundary.
Decision check: Ask the decision owner to accept, modify or defer the case with a written reason. Preserve the minority view even if the selection stands.Define the decision unit
Describe the selected case and the precise objection. Keep the concern about task coverage separate from personal judgments about the reviewer. The artifact should explain what is missing, not characterize someone as difficult for declining to endorse a broader recommendation.
Choose admissible evidence
Include the objection's evidence or the documented absence of relevant examples. Exclude claims about how many readers are affected without appropriate support. Montage coverage limitations should remain visible, because unavailability cannot establish either compatibility or incompatibility for the unreviewed task.
Build the working record
Explain whether the omission changes the case's stated applicability or only suggests further work. A narrow case can remain useful when its boundary is explicit. Do not turn a plausible concern into an observed product failure merely to make the dissent sound stronger.
Test the claim boundary
Ask the decision owner to accept, modify or defer the case with a written reason. Preserve the minority view even if the selection stands. The owner's preference does not itself resolve the factual question about the unreviewed mode of use.
Deliver the review artifact
Deliver the annex beside the chosen case with a reuse boundary and reopening question. Future editors should see the untested task before presenting the case as universal endorsement. The annex records a substantive limitation, not proof of general exclusion or a hidden demographic inference.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The annex records a substantive limitation, not proof of general exclusion or a hidden demographic inference.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.