What should a mutual-citation loop alert establish?
Suppose two explainers about a folding crate cite each other for the same capacity statement. A loop alert prevents reciprocal references from becoming two independent confirmations. It identifies the circular support for that particular claim without dismissing unrelated original observations or speculating about the authors' motives, expertise or honesty.
Use these editorial columns: claim; item_a_passage; item_b_passage; citation_path; outside_basis; support_state; resolving_requirement.
Decision check: Hold the capacity claim if reciprocal assertion is its only basis. Offer narrower attributed wording if appropriate, without implying a false measurement.Name the task and decision
Write the capacity statement exactly and define the support it needs. Trace links relevant to that statement rather than every hyperlink on both pages. Shared navigation or background references do not establish a citation loop supporting the numerical promise at issue in the draft.
Choose the eligible material
Include passages explicitly pointing from one explanation to the other. Exclude unrelated original use descriptions from the loop's evidential basis. Use Montage references where inspectable and preserve unavailable passages; a broken link alone cannot show what the missing source said or whether its support was circular.
Build the reviewable record
Draw the documented closed path and identify any independent specification, measurement or reported experience outside it. Keep source roles distinct. The diagram demonstrates citation structure, not product capacity, and an automated summary of the two pages remains dependent on their existing assertions rather than new confirmation.
Resolve or preserve the limit
Hold the capacity claim if reciprocal assertion is its only basis. Offer narrower attributed wording if appropriate, without implying a false measurement. Do not infer that the stated capacity is wrong merely because support is circular; unsupported and disproven are different dispositions requiring different evidence.
Hand over the next action
Deliver the loop alert with the precise resolving-source requirement and claim location. Preserve unrelated supported material for normal review. The artifact should make a concrete evidence gap actionable without alleging deliberate deception, promising that a suitable independent source exists or declaring the entire product discussion unreliable.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The artifact should make a concrete evidence gap actionable without alleging deliberate deception, promising that a suitable independent source exists or declaring the entire product discussion unreliable.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.