What should an option rejection receipt explain?
For an illustrative research assignment, a team rejects wall-mounted storage because its brief prohibits drilling, despite favorable public reviews. A rejection receipt preserves the hard constraint instead of inventing a product-quality problem. It distinguishes an ineligible option for this task from an inferior product and keeps unverified attachment alternatives out of the compliant set.
Artifact columns: rejected_option; hard_constraint; configuration; installation_passage; eligibility_state; unrelated_benefit; unresolved_alternative.
Decision check: If an accessory could change eligibility, define the missing configuration check. Do not silently add the accessory, assume its availability or dismiss it without evidence.Set the concrete question
Record the excluded option and exact requirement. Preserve no drilling as a hard condition rather than drilling discouraged. Identify the intended configuration so a review of an optional mounting kit cannot automatically establish how the base product attaches or whether the requirement is met.
Select eligible source material
Include explicit installation information. Exclude guesses that a wall fitting requires drilling solely from a photograph. Inspect Montage original references and mark unknown attachment methods as unverified; the team cannot count an attractive option as compliant merely because a non-drilling method seems plausible.
Construct the evidence view
Explain why favorable performance does not compensate for an incompatible installation requirement. Preserve those benefits as separate observations rather than erasing them to justify the selection. A task mismatch should not become an unsupported claim that the product is poor or generally unsuitable.
Check the proposed conclusion
If an accessory could change eligibility, define the missing configuration check. Do not silently add the accessory, assume its availability or dismiss it without evidence. A change to the hard constraint requires an explicit owner decision, not the researcher's preference for the option.
Deliver the bounded output
Deliver exclusion basis, neutral supported benefits and any unresolved alternative. Keep the receipt tied to this brief so future teams can reconsider under different constraints. The artifact records eligibility reasoning, not a universal recommendation, product-failure finding or proof that every possible mounting arrangement was reviewed.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The artifact records eligibility reasoning, not a universal recommendation, product-failure finding or proof that every possible mounting arrangement was reviewed.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.