Skip to content

Separate the evidence finding from the owner's decision

Separate the evidence finding from the owner's decision: A decision record keeps that editorial choice distinct from the finding.

Guides

How can an evidence record distinguish a supported finding from its owner’s editorial choice?

Consider this hypothetical brief: public accounts support a narrow benefit of desktop label holders, but a team chooses not to feature them because the story does not fit the release. A decision record keeps that editorial choice distinct from the finding. Declining the story must not become a claim that the observed benefit was disproven.

Artifact schema and decision check
Editorial worksheet: supported_finding; source_basis; considered_options; owner_choice; stated_rationale; unchanged_evidence; reuse_checks.
Decision check: Describe what remains unchanged in the evidence file and what later reuse still needs to check. A decision not to feature the story does not retire the finding; equally, a supported finding does not automatically authorize a different future publication or broader recommendation.
01 / Guides

Establish the review object

State the supported finding before recording the selection choice. Keep its original task and conditions intact. Do not rewrite the finding negatively simply to make it align with the owner's decision, or imply that public evidence dictated an editorial priority it cannot determine.

02 / Guides

Inspect the relevant support

Include relevant source passages and the owner's actual selection criteria. Exclude invented audience demand or business impact as convenient explanations. Montage references support inspection of the finding, while internal editorial rationale must be attributed to its owner rather than to public sources.

03 / Guides

Record the decision logic

Record considered options and chosen action with the real reason, such as release scope or limited space. Separate a preference from a factual assertion. An automated recommendation may assist discussion, but it does not independently establish which editorial option produces a better outcome.

04 / Guides

Apply the bounded disposition

Describe what remains unchanged in the evidence file and what later reuse still needs to check. A decision not to feature the story does not retire the finding; equally, a supported finding does not automatically authorize a different future publication or broader recommendation.

05 / Guides

Hand over the evidence state

Deliver a two-part record with finding and decision separately attributed. Leave implementation state open until the owner confirms action. Future teams can reuse the bounded evidence without inheriting an unrelated release priority or mistaking the selection outcome for a product-quality verdict.

Keep the boundaries clear.

  • Future teams can reuse the bounded evidence without inheriting an unrelated release priority or mistaking the selection outcome for a product-quality verdict.

Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.

Primary references

Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.

Know what social media shows about you.
Start with a question.

Get started
montage