What should a scope-hole map for an evidence file contain?
Consider this hypothetical brief: a research file covers desk use of a folding tray, yet its recommendation includes travel. A scope-hole map reveals the unsupported portion without implying travel necessarily fails. It compares intended use contexts with actual support and lets the owner narrow the recommendation rather than assuming every empty cell is a negative finding.
Editorial worksheet: intended_setting; required_observation; matching_source; coverage_state; missing_condition; approved_boundary; owner_next_choice.
Decision check: Narrow the recommendation to supported settings or request owner-authorized additional review. Preserve the original intended scope so the change is visible.Establish the review object
List intended settings before placing sources, keeping desk, transit and outdoor use distinct. State what each setting would require the evidence to show. Avoid a broad everyday-use category that lets a desk scene appear to support tasks never described in the inspected file.
Inspect the relevant support
Include explicit accounts of each setting; exclude carrying an empty tray as proof of loaded transit behavior. Use Montage original references and retain unknown conditions. A platform badge or search match cannot establish that the needed task context is actually present or available.
Record the decision logic
Mark covered, partial and unreviewed cells with reasons. Partial may mean the setting is described but loading is unknown. Do not collapse this into failure or success, and do not assign a numerical coverage score that conceals which condition limits the recommendation.
Apply the bounded disposition
Narrow the recommendation to supported settings or request owner-authorized additional review. Preserve the original intended scope so the change is visible. A useful desk recommendation can remain valid while failing the broader travel brief; these are separate judgments rather than contradictory findings.
Hand over the evidence state
Deliver the map with allowed current wording and unresolved uses. Place the central boundary beside the recommendation, not only in the source file. The map organizes evidence gaps; it does not guarantee that future research can fill them or certify suitability for a reader's unreviewed circumstances.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The map organizes evidence gaps; it does not guarantee that future research can fill them or certify suitability for a reader's unreviewed circumstances.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.