What should a source-role index for a mixed brief make inspectable?
Consider a buying-guide file containing manufacturer descriptions, creator demonstrations and user discussions about desk storage. A source-role index shows what each item can contribute to a specific claim. It avoids fabricated credibility scores and blanket authority labels while making clear that a source's usefulness depends on the question being asked.
Use these editorial columns: source; factual_question; source_role; relevant_passage; useful_basis; cannot_establish; disclosure_context.
Decision check: Check the draft for authority leakage between roles. Keep commercial disclosure as context rather than automatic disqualification or an invented numerical penalty.Name the task and decision
List factual questions before classifying sources. Dimensions, visible assembly and repeated ownership experience need different support. A source may be appropriate for one question but not another; do not make its role a permanent label that automatically approves or rejects every passage it contains.
Choose the eligible material
Include explicit descriptions, observations and attributed accounts with their relevant context. Exclude blanket reliable or unreliable classifications without claim-specific reasons. Inspect Montage original references where available and preserve missing source context instead of assuming a familiar publisher name resolves every uncertainty about the statement.
Build the reviewable record
Attach each source to a question it can inform and state what it cannot establish. A demonstration may show one assembly action without long-term durability. A manufacturer description may identify its own stated dimensions without independently confirming an anecdotal performance comparison reported by another writer.
Resolve or preserve the limit
Check the draft for authority leakage between roles. Keep commercial disclosure as context rather than automatic disqualification or an invented numerical penalty. Automated agreement about source quality cannot supply independent product evidence absent from the relevant passages or resolve an unsupported technical claim by itself.
Hand over the next action
Deliver the index with usable roles, limitations and unresolved requirements. Another reviewer should see why a passage is relevant without inheriting a universal judgment about its author. The artifact organizes evidential contribution, not personal trustworthiness, complete source access or a guarantee that every statement in the file is correct.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The artifact organizes evidential contribution, not personal trustworthiness, complete source access or a guarantee that every statement in the file is correct.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.