What should a claim-specific evidence sufficiency note explain?
Consider a reviewer deciding whether public examples support a narrow descriptive sentence about a sorting tray. A sufficiency note explains that local judgment without claiming certainty or complete coverage. It distinguishes adequate support for an illustration from evidence needed for a broad recommendation and preserves material challenges beside the proposed finding.
Use these editorial columns: sentence; implied_scope; necessary_conditions; support_passages; challenge_passages; unresolved_condition; disposition_reason.
Decision check: Choose approve, narrow or hold for this sentence with an inspectable reason. Avoid fabricated confidence scores and guarantees that no contrary evidence exists.Name the task and decision
Write the exact sentence and its likely reader interpretation. Identify whether it describes inspected cases or a wider population. Do not assess an intentionally narrower paraphrase while allowing the broader original to remain in the headline or summary where readers encounter the actual promise.
Choose the eligible material
Include supporting passages and relevant challenges under the same eligibility rule. Exclude sheer source volume as a substitute for necessary context. Montage coverage limitations belong beside the judgment; inaccessible candidates cannot be assumed to agree or disagree simply because the review needs a final disposition.
Build the reviewable record
Explain which necessary conditions are met and unresolved. Keep a reported experience distinct from a verified product property. An automated synthesis can organize this reasoning, but multiple syntheses of the same material do not independently confirm the event, expand its scope or supply missing task conditions.
Resolve or preserve the limit
Choose approve, narrow or hold for this sentence with an inspectable reason. Avoid fabricated confidence scores and guarantees that no contrary evidence exists. If a hard requirement remains unmet, state the shortfall before proposing a smaller useful claim rather than presenting the proposal as original-task completion.
Hand over the next action
Deliver decision, wording and intended-use boundary with source locations. Require renewed review for stronger future summaries. The note records evidence sufficiency for a particular use, not general product approval, legal permission, complete platform access or proof that the owner has implemented the recommended editorial action in public copy.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- The note records evidence sufficiency for a particular use, not general product approval, legal permission, complete platform access or proof that the owner has implemented the recommended editorial action in public copy.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.