What should a surviving-claim card after challenge review explain?
Consider this hypothetical brief: a team began with a promise that drawer dividers prevent clutter, but the reviewed accounts support only easier separation of small items. A surviving-claim card prevents the original behavioral promise from returning through later edits. It preserves the useful observation without presenting a narrowed conclusion as the original hypothesis.
Worksheet columns: original_claim; challenge_basis; surviving_statement; supporting_passages; prohibited_extension; reopen_condition.
Decision check: Write a replacement sentence and an explicit prohibited-extension list. Include synonyms that would restore the same unsupported behavioral guarantee, not merely the original words.Define the decision unit
Copy the original claim verbatim and state the decision it was meant to inform. Distinguish the proposed habit outcome from the physical separation task. Do not rewrite history by pretending the team always intended the smaller claim now supported.
Choose admissible evidence
Include successful separation examples and accounts where dividers did not change tidiness. Exclude inspiration photographs with no reported use. Inspect original Montage references where available and preserve missing context instead of inferring either sustained benefit or lack of benefit.
Build the working record
Explain which part survives: compartments may separate items in described cases while lasting tidiness remains unestablished. Keep source passages beside that reasoning. A plausible habit explanation is not observed behavioral evidence, even if several automated summaries repeat it.
Test the claim boundary
Write a replacement sentence and an explicit prohibited-extension list. Include synonyms that would restore the same unsupported behavioral guarantee, not merely the original words. A change from “prevents” to “eliminates” would not resolve the underlying evidential problem.
Deliver the review artifact
Deliver the card with challenge links and a reopening condition tied to relevant new evidence. Keep the owner's choice separate from the finding. Stronger wording should return only after renewed review, not because a stakeholder finds the narrower statement less persuasive.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- Stronger wording should return only after renewed review, not because a stakeholder finds the narrower statement less persuasive.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-15. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.