How should a disputed label improve the coding rule?
A comment about a smart thermostat may describe both difficult setup and dissatisfaction with automatic scheduling. Reviewers can disagree about its category because the rule does not specify how to handle mixed claims. Adjudication should expose that missing instruction and produce a durable precedent, not merely settle one row so the table looks finished.
Adjudicate the supplied thermostat coding dispute. Identify whether overlap or missing context caused it, draft a precedent and review earlier affected cases.Capture the disputed reasoning
Record the passage, each proposed label and the evidence each reviewer used. Include the relevant surrounding context. Exclude appeals to the author’s presumed intent or reviewer seniority from the decision basis; the classification should rest on the visible statement and a rule another reviewer could apply to a comparable case.
Identify the rule gap
Ask whether the dispute concerns category overlap, insufficient context or a genuinely ambiguous passage. A mixed claim may need multiple codes, while missing context may require unresolved. Do not force an exclusive label unless the research purpose requires one and the rule clearly states how competing claims should be prioritized.
Write and test a precedent
Draft a concise rule with the disputed case and a contrasting near miss. Apply it to several earlier cases that might be affected. If the revised rule changes those classifications, update them explicitly rather than leaving inconsistent labels in the same version of the corpus merely because they were reviewed before the dispute arose.
Deliver an adjudication trail
Hand over the chosen treatment, rule revision and affected records. Keep residual uncertainty where the text cannot decide between categories. If the change alters the meaning of a reported result, regenerate that result under the revised rule and identify the version instead of quietly replacing the disputed row while preserving an obsolete summary.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- A useful adjudication changes the rule where needed, not only the disputed row.
- No example on this page represents a live test or complete platform coverage.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-13. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.