What does agreement between reviewers actually establish?
Two reviewers can consistently classify public coffee grinder discussions and still share a mistaken definition. Agreement is evidence about how reproducibly they apply a rule, not proof that the rule captures the right concept. Evaluate disagreement patterns and category meaning alongside any summary measure, keeping the reviewed set and the procedure explicit for readers.
Evaluate independent coding of supplied grinder discussions. Preserve pre-discussion labels, explain disagreement types and distinguish rule consistency from correctness of the concept.Choose the evaluation set
Select eligible passages that include common cases, boundary cases and unclear context. Keep the selection method visible. Exclude training examples already resolved together if the purpose is an independent application check, since reviewers may remember the agreed answer rather than demonstrate that the rule works on new material under similar conditions.
Code independently first
Give reviewers the same frozen rule and evidence context without sharing provisional labels. Record original assignments before discussion. If one reviewer sees additional context, document the asymmetry. A reconciliation meeting can improve the final labels, but the labels produced after discussion are not independent agreement and should not be reported as though they were.
Inspect disagreement mechanisms
Compare category overlap, missing context and differing interpretation of task outcomes. Use the findings to refine the rule or flag irreducible ambiguity. If reporting a numerical agreement statistic, state its actual method and inputs; do not invent a favorable score or treat one overall value as a substitute for understanding which decisions remain unreliable.
Deliver a bounded assessment
Provide the evaluation set, rule version, original disagreements and changes after review. State whether the exercise supports consistent application within this set. If both reviewers made the same unsupported inference, correct it even though they agreed, and preserve the distinction between reproducibility of coding and validity of the underlying research concept.
Keep the boundaries clear.
- Shared agreement can coexist with a shared interpretive error.
- Badges identify a research context; they do not promise access or complete evidence.
Start with a read-only check: ask your agent to report actual source coverage before collecting records or exporting an audience.
Primary references
Documentation reviewed 2026-11-13. Product capabilities, client availability and plans can change. Third-party marks identify their products, not an affiliation.